Virtual Tour

5065 Sugar Cay CT Carmel, IN 46033 Open Sun 12PM-2PM

UPDATED: 03/26/2026 10:34 PM ON MARKET: 1 days on market

$839,000

4 Beds4 Baths4,541 SqFt

Key Details

Property Type Single Family Home

Sub Type Single Family Residence

Listing Status Active

Purchase Type For Sale

Square Footage 4,541 sqft

Price per Sqft $184

Subdivision Bayhill

MLS Listing ID 22091596

Bedrooms 4

Full Baths 3

Half Baths 1

HOA Fees $305/qua

HOA Y/N Yes

Year Built 1995

Tax Year 2025

Lot Size 0.470 Acres

Acres 0.47

Property Sub-Type Single Family Residence

Location

State IN

County Hamilton

Rooms

Basement Daylight

Interior

Interior Features High Ceilings,Hardwood Floors,Walk-In Closet(s),Paddle Fan,Eat-in Kitchen,Entrance Foyer,Hi-Speed Internet Availbl,Kitchen Island,Pantry

Heating Forced Air,Natural Gas

Cooling Central Air

Fireplaces Number 1

Fireplaces Type Family Room,Gas Starter

Equipment Smoke Alarm,Sump Pump

Fireplace Y

Appliance Dishwasher,Disposal,Gas Water Heater,Microwave,Oven,Convection Oven,Range Hood,Refrigerator

Exterior

Exterior Feature Sprinkler System

Garage Spaces 3.0

Utilities Available Cable Available,Natural Gas Connected

View Y/N false

Building

Story Two

Foundation Concrete Perimeter

Water Public

Architectural Style Traditional

Structure Type Brick,Cement Siding

New Construction false

Schools

Elementary Schools Woodbrook Elementary School

Middle Schools Clay Middle School

High Schools Carmel High School

School District Carmel Clay Schools

Others

HOA Fee Include Association Home Owners,Clubhouse,Maintenance,ParkPlayground,Tennis Court(s)

Ownership Mandatory Fee

Virtual Tour https://360tourdesigns-central-in.hd.pics/5065-Sugar-Cay-Ct/idx

Property Description

Nestled on a .47-acre corner lot in Bayhill at Waterstone, 5065 Sugar Cay Court reflects the timeless appeal and enduring quality that define one of Carmel's most established neighborhoods. With 4,075 finished square feet, a screened porch, deck, finished daylight basement, and 3-car side-load garage, this custom home offers the space, warmth, and thoughtful layout that make everyday living feel both comfortable and refined. A two-story entry opens to formal living and dining rooms and a warm family room with a gas fireplace for relaxed evenings at home. The eat-in kitchen is designed for both daily living and entertaining, featuring Merillat cabinetry, a Maytag in-wall convection oven, built-in microwave, pantry, and adjoining sun room filled with natural light. Crown molding, cased openings, and unified oak flooring bring continuity and classic style throughout the main level. Upstairs, the primary suite offers a private retreat with a tray ceiling, sitting area, two walk-in closets, dual sinks, jetted tub, and separate shower. Three additional bedrooms, each with walk-in closets, plus two additional full baths provide comfortable space for family and guests. The finished daylight basement adds flexibility for recreation, a home office, or additional lounge space, while still offering unfinished storage. Recent updates include roof, paint, and carpeting in 2021, A/C in 2024, powder room refresh in 2024, and gas water heater in 2025. Exterior highlights include brick and composite siding, Pella replacement windows in key living areas and throughout the upper level, a replaced front door, exposed aggregate sidewalk and front porch, in-ground irrigation, and landscape lighting. Waterstone amenities include a clubhouse, pool, playground, tennis, pickleball, and walking paths around Lake Waterstone.